Everyday Carry

13 Best Leather Valet Trays for Men

by Dustin Christensen

best leather valet tray

We may earn a small commission when you make a purchase through our links. Read our editorial & disclosure policy to learn more.


The right valet tray makes organizing your everyday carry items a breeze. Here’s where to start.

Anyone who’s spent any time around me – family, friends, coworkers – knows well my tendency to lose things.

Wallets, keys, passports, children, you name it.

That changed when I replaced the haphazard stack of books on my nightstand with a leather valet tray, or what fancy people call a “catchall.”

It was a game-changer, and one that should’ve happened years ago.

If you’re in the same boat (tray) I was, you’ll appreciate this rundown of our favorite leather valet trays to help finally get your stuff – and life – together.

What to Look For

1

Material: go with thicker leathers and avoid the fake stuff

2

Size: do a quick EDC inventory before deciding on size

3

Structure: some trays are boxy, others are softer and less rigid

4

Aesthetics: rough around the edges or office-appropriate?

5

Warranty: valets can get beat up, so it’s nice to have a warranty

Alta Andina Leather Valet Tray

Alta Andina Leather Valet

What we dig: handcrafted in Colombia and guaranteed for life

This budget-friendly valet is sourced and handmade in the Andes Mountains of South America.

Hand-hammered copper rivets keep the naturally dyed, veg-tanned leather structured to hold keys, watches, wallets and more.

It’s one of the smaller trays on our list (5” x 6”), but its compact size means less space for clutter.

Check Amazon Price

 

Saddleback Leather Firm Leather Valet Tray

Saddleback Leather Firm Leather Valet Tray

What we dig: a premium valet that doesn’t cut corners

Saddleback Leather’s tray features high-quality full-grain leather and a pigskin-lined interior to hold your stuff – and that’s bound to hold up over time.

If not, take up the company on the 100-year guarantee they offer on all leather goods.

This one’s available in black, chestnut, dark coffee and tobacco, and although it sports a boxier structure, it still travels well if you need EDC organization on the go.

Check Amazon Price

 

Bexar Goods Born to Roam Valet Tray

Bexar Goods Born to Roam Valet Tray

What we dig: the roamer’s valet tray of choice

This number’s big, boxy and bold. At 7″ x 8.5″, there’s more than enough room to hold all your stuff without things looking crowded.

The pressure-molded, veg-tanned leather wears a light, natural tone that ages well over time and doesn’t give a damn what you throw on it.

Check Current Price

 

Leatherology Square Valet Tray

Leatherology Square Valet Tray

What we dig: a refined, classy organization option

Instead of using permanent rivets, the Square Valet Tray from Leatherology snaps open and closed, so you can travel with it completely flat or leave it buttoned up at home.

Either way, the 5” x 5” tray is enough to hold small EDC items and look good doin’ it.

The full-grain leather’s available in more than 10 colorways, including cognac, black and ginger.

Check Current Price

 

Faribault Woolen Mill Valet Tray

Faribault Woolen Mill Valet Tray

What we dig: a collaborative effort wherein we all win

This valet is the lovechild of Fairbault Mill and Leather Works Minnesota, the former providing beautiful wool and the latter pitching in a nice handcrafted leather.

Together, these two materials combine to make what can only be described as a dapper valet tray that looks good in any season or setting.

Two sizes are available in two colors and any way you get it, everything’s made by hand in Faribault’s Minnesota mill.

Check Current Price

 

Hide & Drink Leather Catchall

Hide & Drink Leather Catchall

What we dig: our best value pick comin’ in under $25

This H & D tray’s perfect for small EDC budgets and guys who don’t need a massive catchall.

Both the interior and exterior are made with full-grain leather – the inside sports a softer version that’s easy on your stuff, and the outside’s thick and sturdy to stand up over the years.

The only downside? Once you snap this thing up, you only have about 4.5” x 4.5” inside, enough to hold a few items but not much else.

Check Amazon Price

Mark & Graham Baseball Leather Catchall Tray

Mark & Graham Baseball Leather Catchall Tray

What we dig: elegantly inspired by America’s first pastime

Growing up, my uncle had an Audi with a leather interior designed like a baseball glove, stitching and all. This tray’s not that cool, but it’s in the same ballpark. Pun VERY MUCH intended.

This catchall’s made with the same leather used for baseball gloves, though it’s classed up with impeccable stitching and snap closures.

It comes with free monogramming and lays flat for travel.

Check Current Price

 

Billykirk No. 471 Large Valet Tray

Billykirk No. 471 Large Valet Tray

What we dig: a big ol’ tray that gives your EDC room to breathe

Some valet trays end up a hot mess of piled-up items; others, like the Billykirk No. 471, spread the love so you can see exactly what you’ve got goin’ on each morning.

At 9” x 7.5”, this tray’s also great for work or desktops. Pair it with Billykirk’s coin pouch for a little extra organization and call it a day.

Check Current Price

 

Tanner Goods Valet Tray

Tanner Goods Valet Tray

What we dig: a high-end catchall handmade in Portland

Let’s be real, anything coming out of Tanner Goods gets our attention, and this upgraded valet tray is no different.

The tray’s made with two layers of bridle leather and bound with brass rivets that offer a 5” x 5” interior. It’s available in 5 colors, though we’re partial to cognac and saddle tan.

Check Current Price

 

Onward Reserve Bison Leather Valet Tray

Onward Reserve Bison Leather Valet Tray

What we dig: bison beauty that’s all in the details

Each of Onward Reserve’s Bison Leather Trays has a unique aesthetic thanks to the natural variation of the leather.

But it’s the detail of this tray that makes it stand out: small brass rivets, leather tabs at each corner, and hand-stamped branding on the bottom.

It’s the type of catchall that gets passed down through generations, only getting better with age.

Check Current Price

 

American Bench Craft Leather Catchall Valet Tray

American Bench Craft Leather Catchall Valet Tray

What we dig: a thick catchall made by hand in Wilmington, MA

You’d be hard-pressed to find a valet that uses thicker leathers, and that makes this one of the sturdier catchalls on our list.

 At 4.25” x 4.25”, it’s also one the more compact ones, but it’s also a deep 2.5” that offers a bit more volume than shallower trays.

It’s backed by a lifetime guarantee and comes with the option of embossing for a more personalized look.

Check Current Price

 

Go Forth Goods Leather Valet Tray

Go Forth Goods Leather Valet Tray

What we dig: a simply designed, outdoors-inspired catchall

Don’t worry about the 2- to 3-day turnaround time on this tray – it’s worth the wait.

Featuring the brand’s adventure logo, sturdy brass rivets and 10-ounce full grain leather, this valet tray’s a perfect medium size and shape (7” x 7”).

It’s available in mocha, saddle and black, and comes with free customization. If you’re not a fan of most valet trays’ poked-out corners, you’ll love this one’s softer, rounded structure.

Check Current Price

 

Manready Mercantile Leather Valet Tray

Manready Mercantile Leather Valet Tray

What we dig: a minimalist number inspired by Texas work ethic

Manready Mercantile has, in our humble opinion, one of the best mantras around: work hard, live well.

We couldn’t agree more, and a valet tray’s the perfect place to be reminded of it each day.

Their simple catchall comes in a handful of colors from leathers provided by Wicket and Craig of Pennsylvania. Everything’s done by hand in Houston (Astros wassup) and the tray comes in two sizes – 5” x 5” and 8” x 8”.

Check Current Price

 

Next Up in Everyday Carry

For more EDC ideas, join our email newsletter to get epic travel, outdoor and gear ideas delivered weekly.

Get your weekly adventure fix

Join thousands of readers getting epic hiking, camping and travel ideas every week.

Related posts

topo designs y-pack review

Gear Review: Topo Designs Y-Pack

The Y-Pack is a fundamentally simple bag, but it holds up as well as Topo Designs' larger, more rugged packs. Its streamlined focus on the essentials makes it affordable and functional: an ideal combo for day trips and weekend ramblin'.

Gear